Hybrid Cars: Worth the Hype? Consumer Reports Reveals the Truth

by AutoExpert   |  21 March, 2024

Share :

Hybrids promise better gas mileage, but let's be real, they're usually more expensive upfront. So, are they really worth it? Our buddies at Consumer Reports crunched the numbers, and here's the lowdown:

Hybrids That Pay Off FAST

  • Lexus NX

Forget caring about the "hybrid" part, CR says this is the version to get anyway! Faster, smoother, and amazingly, it might even be CHEAPER than the gas-only model. With 38 mpg, you're saving serious money from day one.

Hybrid Cars

  • Ford Maverick

The hybrid's standard here, which means two wins: cheaper to buy AND cheaper to drive (37 mpg!). If you're looking at a Maverick, don't even consider the gas version.

Hybrid Cars

  • Lexus RX

Okay, it's a tiny bit more expensive, but the hybrid gets 34 mpg, meaning you'll make up that difference in, like, six months. No-brainer upgrade here.

Hybrid Cars

  • Toyota Corolla

Cheap car + insane gas mileage (48 mpg) = killer combo. The hybrid's barely pricier than the gas version, so you'll be saving money in basically no time.

Hybrid Cars

  • Toyota Highlander

Want a three-row SUV with good mileage? Good luck finding another that beats the Highlander hybrid's 35 mpg. Yeah, it'll cost a bit more upfront, but that extra fuel savings adds up FAST.

Hybrid Cars

  • Hyundai Tucson

CR says the hybrid's just BETTER than the gas model, period. It's a little pricier, but 35 mpg beats the gas version by a landslide. Expect to break even in about 3 years.

Hybrid Cars

  • Honda CR-V

Another one where the hybrid wins on all fronts. 35 mpg makes a big difference, and CR says you'll start saving compared to a gas CR-V in roughly 3 years.

Hybrid Cars

Hybrids Where You'll Wait FOREVER to Save Money

  • Ford F-150

Ouch. CR's test showed the hybrid getting a measly 1 mpg better than the gas-only version. And it costs WAY more. You'd be waiting decades to break even. Skip it.

Hybrid Cars

  • Kia Sorento

Not as bad as the F-150, but even 3 mpg better isn't enough to justify the price jump. CR predicts a 13-year wait to see savings...yikes.

Hybrid Cars

  • Honda Accord

The top-trim Accords are all hybrids now, so it might be a good upgrade if you want those fancy features anyway. But if you're comparing a base model gas Accord to the hybrid...well, it could take 9 years to break even.

Hybrid Cars

Important note: Gas prices and how much you drive totally affect these numbers! If gas is crazy expensive where you live, or you rack up a ton of miles, the payoff could be way faster.

Anything on here surprise you? Let us know in the comments!

Recomended:

BMW XM Gets An 888-HP Makeover With Manhart's MHXM 900 II Package - Photo
Tuning
BMW XM Gets An 888-HP Makeover With Manhart's MHXM 900 II Package

The BMW XM hasn’t exactly been flying off showroom floors, with just over 7,200 units sold globally last year. This year isn’t shaping up much better—U.S. sales were already down 14.

AutoExpert
America’s SUV Obsession: The Evolution of Big, Bold Rides - Photo
Others
America’s SUV Obsession: The Evolution of Big, Bold Rides

Oh, let’s switch gears and chat more casually about America’s long-standing crush on SUVs! So, picture this: it's not just about their beefy looks or how many groceries you can cram in

AutoExpert
How Much Does It Cost to Charge a Kia EV9? - Photo
Others
How Much Does It Cost to Charge a Kia EV9?

So, you're curious аbout the cost of charging a Kia EV9, right? Well, let us give you the lowdown on this sleek beаst from South Korea. The EV9 is Kia's top-tier, three-row electric SUV that&#

AutoExpert
Is the Tesla Model Y the Perfect Used EV for You? - Photo
Others
Is the Tesla Model Y the Perfect Used EV for You?

So, hаve you been checking out the Tesla Model Y? It’s pretty аwesome and only hit the roаds in 2020, making it the newest kid on the block from Tesla. It’s got more room and sits higher t

AutoExpert
Renault Brings Back The Beast: 5 Turbo 3E Hits Production In 2026 - Photo
Car News
Renault Brings Back The Beast: 5 Turbo 3E Hits Production In 2026

Renault’s 5 Turbo 3E concept is heading to production in 2026, bringing a fresh, all-electric take on the iconic Turbo. It’s designed to deliver incredible performance and tech, makin

AutoExpert
Mercedes-Benz CEO Ola Källenius Named ACEA President For 2025 - Photo
Car News
Mercedes-Benz CEO Ola Källenius Named ACEA President For 2025

The European Automobile Manufacturers' Association (ACEA) has named Ola Källenius, CEO of Mercedes-Benz, as its president, marking a significant change in the organization's leadership. A

AutoExpert
Subaru Takes The Crown In 2024 Car Reliability Rankings, Outshining Lexus And Toyota - Photo
Car News
Subaru Takes The Crown In 2024 Car Reliability Rankings, Outshining Lexus And Toyota

Consumer Reports just dropped its list of the most reliable car brands for 2024, and Subaru snagged the top spot, beating out Lexus and Toyota. The rankings are based on feedback from actual car owner

AutoExpert
Toyota Unveils The Urban Cruiser, A New Electric SUV For Europe - Photo
Car News
Toyota Unveils The Urban Cruiser, A New Electric SUV For Europe

Toyota has unveiled its latest electric SUV, the Urban Cruiser, which is essentially a rebranded Suzuki e-Vitara, with some subtle tweaks to give it a more distinct Toyota feel. The Urban Cruiser is a

AutoExpert
Subaru Launches STI Sport R-Black Limited Editions For WRX S4 And Levorg - Photo
Car News
Subaru Launches STI Sport R-Black Limited Editions For WRX S4 And Levorg

Subaru has unveiled the STI Sport R-Black Limited editions for the WRX S4 and Levorg in Japan, adding an extra touch of style and exclusivity to the performance sedan and wagon. These new flagship tri

AutoExpert
Electric Godzilla: Nissan Brings The R32 GT-R Into The EV Age - Photo
Car News
Electric Godzilla: Nissan Brings The R32 GT-R Into The EV Age

Nissan has been working on an electric version of the iconic GT-R R32 since March 2023, and it’s finally ready to step into the spotlight. Created by a team of volunteer engineers, this unique E

AutoExpert